The Shays and Whiskey Rebellions

Essential Question

What was the effect of Shay’s Rebellion? What was the effect of The Whiskey Rebellion?

Shays' Rebellion

SHEG-How did Americans react to Shays’ rebellion_.pptx

Activity 1: How did Americans react to Shays’ Rebellion?

  1. Read the textbook passage about Shays’ Rebellion and answer the following questions:

    1. What happened in Shay’s rebellion?

    2. How is it connected to the Articles of Confederation?

    3. According to the textbook, how did Americans respond?

  2. The common story about Shays’ rebellion is that the Founding Fathers realized that the Articles of Confederation were too weak and thought that the central government needed more power to control popular uprisings. The question is did all Americans think the Articles of Confederation were too weak? How did Americans react to Shays’ Rebellion?

  3. Quietly read Thomas Jefferson Letter on Shays’ rebellion and answer the Guiding Questions.

SHEG-How did Americans react to Shays’ rebellion Student Version.pdf

Discussion Questions

  • What are the pros and cons of a strong central government?

  • Why might Jefferson oppose having a strong central government?

  • Why would the idea of poor farmers rebelling be scary to many of the people at the Constitutional Convention?

  • Do you agree with Jefferson’s assertion about the “tree of liberty?”

  • How does this letter challenge or expand the textbook’s account?

  • Why might many textbooks make it seem like everyone wanted a strong central government after Shays’ Rebellion?

The Whiskey Rebellion

A conflict arose over the government’s tax on whiskey, part of Hamilton’s financial plan. From Pennsylvania to Georgia, outraged farmers resisted the tax. For them, whiskey—and the grain it was made from—were important products. Because of poor roads, backcountry farmers had trouble getting their grain to market. Crops such as wheat and rye were more easily carried to market in liquid form, so farmers made their grain into whiskey. A farmer’s horse could haul only two bushels of rye but could carry two barrels of rye whiskey which were equal to 24 bushels of the grain. In addition, their customers paid more for whiskey than grain. With little cash to buy goods, let alone pay the tax, farmers used whiskey as money to get whatever supplies they needed and traded whiskey for salt, sugar, and other goods.


In the summer of 1794, a group of farmers in western Pennsylvania staged the Whiskey Rebellion against the tax. One armed group beat up a tax collector, coated him with tar and feathers, and stole his horse. Others threatened an armed attack on Pittsburgh. Washington, urged on by Hamilton, was prepared to enforce the tax and crush the Whiskey Rebellion. They feared that failing to act might undermine the new government and weaken its authority. In October 1794, General Henry Lee, with Hamilton at his side, led an army of 13,000 soldiers into western Pennsylvania to put down the uprising. As news of the army’s approach spread, the rebels fled. After much effort, federal troops rounded up 20 bare-foot, ragged prisoners. Washington had proved his point. He had shown that the government had the power and the will to enforce its laws.

Discussion Questions

  • How did George Washington react to the Whiskey Rebellion? Why?

The Effects of the Rebellions

Shay's Rebellion

The delegates (representatives) worked to create a stronger central government that would (quoting from the opening of the Constitution) “establish justice” and “insure domestic tranquility.” The strength of the central government helped to put the rebellion to rest. Shay’s Rebellion is thought to be one reason why people rallied behind the Constitution

Whiskey Rebellion

This action set a precedent (example) for the new federal government’s authority, even in the affairs of individual states. Thomas Jefferson and some of his peers were appalled by the overwhelming use of governmental force, which they feared might be a first step to absolute power.

Activity 3: What were the causes and effects of Shay's Rebellion?

Using the information from this lesson, answer the questions in a thinking map. Complete this assignment digitally or on paper. It will be collected in your portfolio.

Activity 4: What were the causes and effects of the Whiskey Rebellion?

Using the information from this lesson, answer the questions in a thinking map. Complete this assignment digitally or on paper. It will be collected in your portfolio.

Extension Activities